Backyard Grilling: Propane vs. Charcoal

Propane Grill: Pros and Cons

Of all the backyard grills on the market, propane grills are widely appreciated for their convenience, speed, and ease of use, making them a go-to option for many backyard chefs. With the simple twist of a knob and push of an igniter button, you’re ready to grill in under 10 minutes. This makes propane grills especially appealing for weeknight dinners or last-minute gatherings where time is limited. The ability to adjust heat instantly means better control over cooking temperatures, allowing you to sear steaks, roast vegetables, or cook delicate items like fish with confidence.

Another advantage is cleanliness. Propane burns cleanly, producing less smoke and minimal residue compared to charcoal. There’s no ash to deal with, and flare-ups are generally easier to control. Refueling is also fairly straightforward—just replace or refill the propane tank when needed.

However, propane grills come with a few drawbacks. The upfront cost is often higher than that of charcoal grills, and replacement parts like burners or igniters may wear out over time. Also, many grilling purists argue that propane lacks the distinctive smoky flavor that charcoal imparts to food. If flavor authenticity is your top priority, propane might feel underwhelming. Despite these cons, for anyone who values simplicity, propane grills are a smart and efficient choice.

View Selection

Charcoal Grill: Pros and Cons

Charcoal grills offer an unmatched smoky flavor that many barbecue lovers consider the hallmark of real grilling. Whether you’re slow-cooking ribs or searing steaks, the rich aroma of burning charcoal infuses food with a depth of flavor that propane simply can’t replicate. For traditionalists, the hands-on experience of building a fire, managing coals, and fanning flames adds to the authenticity and satisfaction of the grilling ritual. Charcoal grills also tend to be more affordable initially, making them accessible to a wide range of users.

Performance-wise, charcoal grills excel in creating high, direct heat and maintaining long cooking sessions. They’re ideal for low-and-slow smoking or high-heat searing. With practice, users can learn to manipulate coal placement and airflow vents to create different heat zones, adding versatility to their cooking method.

But charcoal does have its downsides. It takes more time to light and preheat—typically 20 to 30 minutes. Temperature control is manual, requiring more attention and skill. Cleaning up ashes can be messy, and handling charcoal can be dusty and cumbersome. Additionally, storing bags of charcoal and lighter fluid takes up space and can present safety concerns. Still, if bold flavor and traditional grilling appeal to you, charcoal may be well worth the extra effort.

View Selection